Skip to content
Logo mtc Berlin - Zur Startseite Logo mtc Berlin - Zur Startseite

Accessibility Overlays - A Critical Perspective

Accessibility overlays are third-party solutions that claim to automatically fix accessibility issues on websites through JavaScript-based tools that modify the website’s interface when activated by users. These tools have become increasingly popular as organizations seek quick ways to address accessibility concerns, but they have also generated significant controversy in the accessibility community.

What Are Accessibility Overlays?

Accessibility overlays typically provide features such as:

  • Text resizing and spacing options
  • Color contrast adjustments
  • Screen readers and text-to-speech functionality
  • Navigation assistance
  • Content simplification
  • Focus indicators and keyboard navigation tools

These tools are often marketed as simple, one-click solutions to make websites compliant with accessibility standards like WCAG and regulations like the ADA.

The Controversy Around Overlays

Most accessibility experts and advocates express significant concerns about overlay solutions, particularly those marketed as complete accessibility fixes. Here are some key issues:

Limitations of Automated Fixes

Overlays cannot fix all accessibility issues, particularly those requiring structural changes to the website’s code. Some critical problems they typically fail to address include:

  • Improper heading structures
  • Missing alternative text for meaningful images
  • Inaccessible forms and error messages
  • Complex interactive elements like custom widgets
  • Keyboard trap issues
  • Proper semantic markup

User Experience Concerns

Many users with disabilities report that overlays can:

  • Conflict with their existing assistive technologies
  • Create confusing or inconsistent experiences
  • Add extra steps before accessing content
  • Increase page load times
  • Provide features that duplicate functionality they already have

Organizations should be aware that:

  • Several websites using overlays have still faced accessibility lawsuits
  • Using an overlay does not guarantee legal compliance
  • Relying solely on overlays may create a false sense of security

When Might Overlays Be Useful?

Despite the significant limitations, there are some scenarios where thoughtfully implemented overlay features could provide value:

  1. As a supplementary tool rather than a complete solution
  2. When developed alongside the main website as an integrated part of the design
  3. For specific, targeted functionality that enhances user experience
  4. As a temporary measure while more comprehensive accessibility improvements are being implemented
  5. When focused on personalization options rather than claiming to “fix” accessibility

Best Practices for Using Overlay Features

If considering overlay technology as part of your accessibility strategy:

  • Don’t rely on them as your only solution — prioritize building accessibility into your core design and development
  • Test with actual users with disabilities using various assistive technologies
  • Be transparent about limitations and ongoing accessibility efforts
  • Choose solutions that focus on enhancement rather than claiming to make your site “instantly compliant”
  • Integrate accessibility features directly into your site rather than using third-party plug-ins when possible
  • Consult with accessibility experts who can provide guidance on genuine accessibility improvements

A Balanced Approach

The most effective approach to digital accessibility is to:

  1. Build accessibility into your design and development processes from the beginning
  2. Conduct regular manual testing with diverse users
  3. Use automated testing tools to identify basic issues
  4. Provide ongoing training for your team on accessibility best practices
  5. Consider overlay features only as supplementary tools for personalization, not as compliance solutions